News

Sonya Massey’s family says Grayson trial verdict is a ‘miscarriage of justice’

Sonya Massey’s family says Grayson trial verdict is a ‘miscarriage of justice’

Left to right: Anthony Romanucci, James Wilburn, Teresa Haley, and Sontae Massey, all speaking with a reporter Wednesday afternoon in downtown Peoria. Photo: Saga Communications/Will Stevenson


Peoria, IL (CAPITOL CITY NOW) – Irate might be the only word to describe the family of Sonya Massey after now-former Sheriff’s Deputy Sean Grayson was convicted Wednesday of Second Degree Murder, fifteen months after her death.

The family members praised John Milhiser, Sangamon County State’s Attorney, for his work on the case, and that of First Assistant State’s Attorney Mary Beth Rodgers.  Who they didn’t praise, was Grayson himself — or the justice system.

“The justice system did exactly what it’s designed to do.  It’s not meant for us,” said Sontae Massey, Sonya’s cousin, suggesting that the fact that there was only one person of color on the nine-man, four-woman jury, wasn’t fair at all, and needs to be changed.  “I will dedicate my life to dismantling the system that created this problem.  The fight has just begun for me.”

Massey’s father, James Wilburn, took aim at the shooter.

“Sean Grayson shouldn’t be able to get out of jail,” said Wilburn.  “My daughter could get out of that burial vault, walk out of Oakwood Cemetery.  I know that plot that’s waiting for him, he can get to it as soon as he can.  It wouldn’t make me any difference at all.”

Grayson’s mother, at one point, embraced Donna Massey, Sonya’s mother, as the trial started last week.  Both sides agreed they couldn’t fathom what the other is doing.

Anthony Romanucci, an Illinois-based attorney who’s been part of the team representing the Massey family was a little more circumspect, while agreeing the verdict was the one that his side didn’t want.

“Was Sonya a threat?  The unequivocal answer is no.  She was not a threat.  She was never a threat, and that’s what was proven in this court,” said Romanucci.  “The difference is that the jury found that there was some issue of self-defense.”

The jury likely believed that the pot of boiling water on Massey’s stove was meant for police, and at least, may have been readied to throw at Grayson.  Second Degree Murder essentially means while Grayson killed Massey, there was no pre-meditation for the act.  It also means a lesser sentence — a maximum of 20 years, with Grayson only having to serve no more than ten years.

Even so, Romanucci told reporters at a press conference after the verdict was announced, the public, and the Massey family, could still call Grayson a “murderer,” based on the conviction.

One observer suggested that, given Grayson has been diagnosed with cancer, it is a good thing.

Grayson’s defense team, and his family members, could not be located after the verdict, nor could Milhiser and Rodgers.

Recent Headlines

22 hours ago in Entertainment, Music

Kendrick Lamar leads 2026 Grammy nominations, followed by Lady Gaga, Jack Antonoff and Cirkut

Not like us? More like him: Kendrick Lamar leads the 2026 Grammy Award nominations, announced Friday.

22 hours ago in Entertainment, IL State News, Local

Elephants, clowns, and BIG fun at the Ansar Shrine Circus

Family fun and a community backed weekend at the Ansar Shrine Circus.

1 day ago in Education, Entertainment, History, IL State News, Local

One of the most popular speeches in our nation is on display right here in Springfield, IL

Abraham Lincoln Presidential Library and Museum

"Four score and seven years ago....." Sound familiar? Read the Gettysburg Address in Lincolns own hand!

1 day ago in Entertainment

Shaggy recounts his relief mission to Jamaica after Hurricane Melissa and shares how you can help

After the devastating October storm that killed at least 75 people across the northern Caribbean, Shaggy, 57, mobilized relief immediately for Jamaica, shuttling supplies from Miami and hand delivering them to the worst-hit areas.

1 day ago in Entertainment, Music

The 2026 Grammy Award nominations are about be announced. Here’s what to know

Nominees will be announced during a video livestream on the Grammy website and the Recording Academy's YouTube channel on Friday at 8 a.m. Pacific and 11 a.m. Eastern.